Today’s digital landscape demands robust and secure user identity management. Two prominent options stand out: on-premises Active Directory (AD) and cloud-based Microsoft Entra ID (formerly Azure AD). Understanding their key differences is crucial for choosing the right solution. In this post, we will talk about the differences and how to choose between the two.
On-Premises Active Directory: Familiar and Established
First, let’s explain what on-premises Active Directory is.
On-Premises Active Directory (AD) refers to the traditional, locally hosted version of Microsoft’s Active Directory service. Active Directory is a directory service that provides a central location for network administration and security. It’s commonly used in Windows environments to manage and authenticate users, computers, and other resources within a network.
In the context of “on-premises,” it means that the Active Directory infrastructure is installed, configured, and maintained on servers physically located within an organization’s own data center or on-site IT facilities. This is in contrast to cloud-based directory services, such as Azure Active Directory (Azure AD), which is hosted in the Microsoft Azure cloud.
On-Premises Active Directory typically involves domain controllers, which are servers responsible for authenticating and authorizing users and computers within a Windows domain. The domain controllers store the Active Directory database, which includes information about users, groups, computers, and other network objects.
Organizations using On-Premises Active Directory have full control over the infrastructure but are also responsible for its maintenance, security, and scalability. This contrasts with cloud-based directory services, where some of these responsibilities are shifted to the cloud service provider.
As technology evolves, hybrid solutions that combine on-premises and cloud-based directory services are becoming more common, allowing organizations to leverage the benefits of both approaches.
So, what are the key features and benefits of AD’s?
- Familiar interface: AD’s familiarity minimizes the learning curve for IT teams accustomed to its established practices.
- Granular control: Administrators have full control over user access and permissions, ensuring compliance and data security.
- Data privacy: Data resides within your infrastructure, potentially enhancing data privacy and control.
- Cost-effective: Eliminates ongoing subscription fees associated with cloud-based solutions.
Microsoft Entra ID: Cloud-Based Agility and Scalability
Microsoft Entra ID formerly, Azure AD, or Azure Active Directory, is Microsoft’s cloud-based identity and access management service. It is a comprehensive identity and access management solution that combines directory services, advanced identity protection, application access management, and a host of other capabilities. Some of its features and benefits include:
- Cloud-based: Leverages Azure’s scalability and resilience, eliminating dedicated infrastructure needs.
- Simplified management: Centralized management in the cloud reduces administrative overhead.
- Scalability: Adapts to user growth without additional hardware investment.
- Enhanced security: Utilizes Microsoft’s robust security infrastructure and advanced threat detection capabilities.
- Anywhere access: Enables secure access from any device, anytime, anywhere.
- VPN-free remote management: Allows secure remote device management without VPNs, especially when combined with a robust RMM tool.
- Cost-effective: The free version of Entra ID offers core features and significant storage space, potentially saving costs.
Choosing the Right Solution
The ideal choice depends on your specific needs and priorities. Consider factors like:
- IT expertise: AD requires more internal expertise, while Entra ID leverages Microsoft’s expertise.
- Budget: AD may be cost-effective upfront, but Entra ID’s free tier and scalability can offer long-term savings.
- Security: Both offer robust security features, with Entra ID benefiting from Microsoft’s advanced cloud-based security.
- Mobility: Entra ID excels in enabling remote access and mobile workforce support.
- Integration: Consider your existing systems and the ease of integration with each solution.
Both AD and Entra ID offer powerful identity management capabilities. Carefully evaluate your needs and priorities to make the best choice for your organization.
Keep your business running smoothly with Managed IT Services. Contact Solzorro in Salt Lake City today!